Guide · Charity Golf Outings

Charity Golf Tournament Formats: Scramble, Shamble & Best Ball

Pick a format that fits your field, your pace, and your scoring plan — then write it down in the rules you send with registration.

✓ Scramble✓ Shamble✓ Best ball / four-ball✓ USGA allowances✓ When to use each

Quick Comparison

ScrambleShambleBest ball (four-ball)
How it playsBest shot, every strokeBest drive, then own ballOwn ball the whole hole
Team scoreOne score per holeLow ball (or low two) after own-ball playLow ball (or low two)
PaceUsually the fastestSlower than a scrambleSlowest of the three
Best forMixed skill, large charity fieldsGroups that want more real golfStronger, even fields
4-person handicap (USGA)25/20/15/10 combinedCommittee guidance: 65% each85% each in stroke play

Handicap figures are the USGA's recommended allowances or, for shamble, committee guidance — not a requirement. Many charity outings use flights instead of handicaps. See the USGA scramble and shamble committee pages, and Appendix C of the Rules of Handicapping for four-ball.

Scramble

Every player tees off. The team picks the best shot, and everyone plays their next shot from that spot (typically within a club-length, no closer to the hole, and in the same condition — fairway stays fairway). Repeat until the ball is holed, and record one team score. Many events require each player's drive to be used a minimum number of times (often 2–4 in a four-person scramble) so one long hitter doesn't play every tee shot.

This is the usual charity format because it keeps a shotgun moving and lets high-handicappers contribute. For mulligans, string, red-tee shots, and buying strokes off the final score, see the charity scramble rules guide, which includes a sample rules sheet and a stroke calculator.

Shamble

Everyone tees off and the team selects the best drive. From there, each player plays their own ball into the hole. The team score is usually the lowest individual score on the hole; some events count the two lowest. A shamble feels more like regular golf than a scramble does, and it takes longer, which matters if your course is tight on a shotgun window or you have a large field.

USGA committee guidance for a selected-drive shamble suggests considering 75% of each player's course handicap for a two-person team, or 65% for a four-person team. Those are individual allowances, not a single combined team handicap. Confirm the method in your terms of competition.

Best Ball (Four-Ball)

Each player plays their own ball from tee to hole. The team's score is the best individual score (or the best two, if you say so in the rules). There is no shared shot. This format suits groups that already play a lot of golf and want a more serious competition. It is the slowest of the three, so think twice for a full 144-player shotgun with a tight lunch window.

The USGA's recommended handicap allowance for four-ball stroke play is 85% of each player's course handicap (90% in four-ball match play). Apply the allowance to the unrounded course handicap, then round, as described in the Rules of Handicapping.

Handicaps, Flights, or Neither

  • USGA-style team or individual allowances — fairest if you have reliable course handicaps. For a 4-person scramble the recommended team handicap is 25% / 20% / 15% / 10% of course handicaps, lowest to highest; 30% / 20% / 10% for three players; 35% / 15% for two. The handicap strokes calculator can compute the scramble figures.
  • Flights — group teams by combined handicap, average score, or a simple A/B/C/D split, and award each flight. Common when not every player has an index.
  • Straight gross, plus fundraising strokes — some charity scrambles skip handicaps and let money raised turn into strokes off the final score, with a cap. WhatUGet Outings uses that model: net = gross − purchased strokes − team handicap (which can be zero).
Planning the rest of the outing?
Work backwards from your date with the free outing checklist, or start from the step-by-step organizer guide.
Score a charity scramble without an app download

WhatUGet Outings (beta) is built for a scramble with one team score per hole: captains enter scores from a QR code in any phone browser, purchased strokes come off the live net leaderboard, and you can print scorecards, cart signs, and starter sheets. Free to run through October 2027; sponsor features are on the $69/yr organizer plan. It is not a registration or payment platform.

Try WhatUGet Outings

FAQ

What is the most common format for a charity golf tournament?

A four-person scramble. Every player hits, the team plays from the best shot, and one score is recorded per hole. It is usually the fastest format and the easiest for mixed-ability groups.

What is the difference between a scramble and a shamble?

In a scramble, the team plays every shot from the chosen ball. In a shamble, everyone tees off, the team picks the best drive, and then each player finishes the hole with their own ball. A shamble plays more like regular golf after the tee shot and usually takes longer.

What is best ball in a charity outing?

Best ball is four-ball: each player plays their own ball for the entire hole, and the team's score is the lowest (or lowest two) individual scores. It rewards consistent golfers and is slower than a scramble.

What handicap allowance should we use?

The USGA publishes recommended allowances. For a 4-person scramble it is 25% / 20% / 15% / 10% of course handicaps, lowest to highest, added together for a team handicap. For four-ball stroke play the recommended individual allowance is 85%. For a 4-person shamble, USGA committee guidance suggests considering 65% of each player's course handicap. Many charity events skip handicaps and use flights instead. Put the choice in your rules sheet.

Can I run a shamble or best ball in WhatUGet?

WhatUGet Outings (beta) is built around a scramble: one team score per hole, with optional purchased strokes and a team handicap. You can still use the printables and shotgun tools for other formats, but scoring is one score per team per hole.